What to Expect from Your First Individual Counseling Session
Are you feeling overwhelmed, stuck, or simply unsure where to turn next? You're not alone, and individual counseling might be the breakthrough you need. Whether you're facing anxiety, navigating life transitions, or just need a space to sort through your thoughts, individual counseling in Kalamazoo, MI, can offer real support and clarity. At the Rinehart Institute, many first-time clients start with questions like, What happens in a therapy session? What should I bring? Is it normal to feel nervous? In this blog, we’ll walk you through exactly what to expect from your first individual counseling session, from the initial intake to common concerns.
The Intake Process: What Happens?
Your first individual counseling session is all about building a foundation. It typically begins with an intake process, where you’ll complete forms about your personal history, current concerns, medical background, and goals for therapy. This might be done online beforehand or in the waiting room before your session.
Once you’re with your therapist, the conversation will focus on getting to know who you are, what brought you in, and what you hope to accomplish. Don’t worry about saying the “right thing.” There’s no script. This is your space to be open, honest, and human. During this first session, your therapist will likely ask questions to get a clearer picture of your life, struggles, strengths, and what type of support will help you most.
Your Therapy Starter Kit: What to Bring and How to Prepare
Let’s be real—your first counseling session isn’t a pop quiz, and you don’t need to show up with your life perfectly organized. But a little preparation can make you feel a whole lot more at ease. Here’s what can help:
- Jot down your thoughts. Don’t worry about being eloquent—scribble a few notes about what’s been bothering you or what you want to change.
- Medication list? Bring it. Especially if you’re taking anything regularly or have a history of mental health treatment.
- Insurance info or payment method. It’s just one less thing to worry about at the front desk.
- Most important of all? An open mind. You might feel awkward, nervous, or even scared. That’s okay. You’re showing up for yourself, and that’s powerful.
Busting the Myths: What Therapy Is Like
Let’s talk about the thoughts that creep in when you’re considering therapy. Maybe you’re worried you’ll get emotional, say the wrong thing, or feel awkward. These fears are common but often based on myths that just aren’t true.
- Myth #1: You must be in crisis to go to therapy.
Reality: Many people start individual counseling not because they’re at rock bottom but because they want clarity, self-awareness, or support through life’s challenges.
- Myth #2: Therapy is just talking about your feelings.
Reality: Yes, you’ll talk—but you’ll also gain perspective, strategies, and tools. Individual counseling is a collaborative process. It’s designed to help you move forward, not just look back.
- Myth #3: Therapists are distant.
Reality: A great therapist is warm, compassionate, and trained to make you feel heard, especially when you don’t quite know how to express what’s going on. You’re not expected to have the perfect words; you’re just expected to show up.
Ready to Begin?
Whether you’re seeking clarity, healing, or simply someone to talk to, individual counseling in Kalamazoo, MI, offers the support you deserve. The compassionate professionals at the Rinehart Institute are here to walk with you, one step at a time. Call today to schedule your first session.


